Best Cheese Shop New Haven Near Me

4worldlovers: In 1999, we took a leap of faith and bought the historic Arethusa Farm, first established by the Webster family in 1868. The family had long since sold the property and over the years it had fallen into disrepair and was slated for development. We didn’t know yet how we would use it, but couldn’t bear the thought of Litchfield losing that open space. Since that fateful day it seems each day has been a new beginning.

Before long, it became apparent that the farm should once again be a dairy, as it had been for over a hundred years. Our first foray into dairying was simple enough, just five cows roaming the hilly pastures. But one thing led to another and soon the old barns were renovated and new ones added, until we had dedicated housing and pasture for the more than 300 cows that reside there today. From the beginning we’ve been committed to providing an outstanding level of care to our herd and it didn’t take long for these high standards to pay off in the form of exquisitely clean, rich milk.

It was this exceptional milk that ultimately led us to build a small dairy plant in the historic Bantam firehouse; it seemed only fitting that we use a building steeped in history to create “milk like it used to taste”. Following the dairy’s success, we opened the award-winning restaurant Arethusa al tavolo in 2014 and, then the bakery Arethusa a mano. Finally, just when we thought we were done, the opportunity arose to add a second dairy store in downtown New Haven and a third location in West Hartford Center. As our family of businesses continues to grow, each new endeavor is driven by our desire to share the quality of Arethusa products with our friends and neighbors.

At our dairy plant in Bantam, CT we produce and package each and every Arethusa Farm Dairy product. From milk to ice cream to butter, our dairy plant uses specific processing techniques to ensure the uttermost quality resides within our products.

Arethusa al tavolo is a complete dairy-to-table experience which showcases products from the dairy as well as the best Executive Chef Dan Magill has to offer. Conveniently located next to the dairy processing plant in Bantam, CT - we hope you can come experience Open Table's "Top 100 in America" restaurant for two years in a row.

Using Arethusa products, we strive to highlight the freshness of our dairy, with how fresh we can make our baked goods. Seeking a coffee with parallel standards, we looked to Stumptown Coffee Roasters, where harvesting by hand and carefully selecting the fruit is their highest standard. Stumptown roasts the beans on demand every week giving us a cup of coffee unlike any other. Together, our standards create an experience that is truly by hand. a mano.

4worldlovers:
Enjoy fresh sandwiches, salads, soups and so much more. Our friendly staff will take great care of you. Enjoy lunch outside on our patio.

The best Meatball sub! Bruno knocks it out of the park every time!

Great food, nice and good choice of imported Italian products, really friendly, I like it

A few times we ordered from P&M on Uber eats while living in a different part of New Haven. The sandwiches were all fantastic. Now that we're living in the neighborhood we eat breakfast or brunch outside the store frequently. The food is amazing and the staff are so friendly.

P & M Fine Foods has been your local gourmet go-to shop in New Haven, CT.

Along with our delicious menus, we offer a variety of specialty items as well.